By Anna Triponel and John Sherman


On the evening of 23 March 2017, just as the deadline for a decision was approaching, the French Constitutional Court declaredthat the French law on the duty of vigilance (or duty of care) owed by parent and contracting companiesis constitutional and will remain on the books, albeit without the corresponding financial sanctions for companies. In this article, we pinpoint opportunities and potential pitfalls of the law by comparing it with the authoritative global standard on business’ responsibility for their impacts on people: the United Nations Guiding Principleson Business and Human Rights (the ‘Guiding Principles’).

The French law is a significant development for the field of business and human rights. As the IBA observed last year in its Practical Guide and Reference Annex, there has been increasing legislation inspired by the soft law norms of the Guiding Principles. The most recent, and the most striking, example of this global convergence on the Guiding Principles is the French law on the duty of vigilance. It blends together French tort law with the concept of human rights due diligence in the Guiding Principles –a core feature of the Guiding Principles –which enables companies to prevent and address harm to people as they conduct their day-to-day business. As was discussed in parliamentary debates, the French law seeks to ‘implement the legal principle of due diligence, recommended by the Guiding Principles’.

How this law is interpreted by French judges and implemented by companies moving forward will have a considerable bearing on how companies can avoid harming people in their day-to-day business, as well as on similar legislative developments in other countries. To reach its full potential of enabling companies to identify and address human rights harm, it is imperative that this law builds upon the concepts contained in the Guiding Principles that inspired it.

Ever since the 2013 Rana Plaza tragedy, in which over 1,100 workers lost their lives while making clothes in Bangladesh for European and American brands, French parliamentarians have been discussing ways to strengthen the accountability of parent companies for their activities, and those of their suppliers, overseas. The duty of vigilance law, adopted by the French National Assembly in February 2017, is the outcome of that discussion. It asks the largest French companies, approximately 150 of them, to develop, publish and effectively implement a ‘vigilance plan’ or ‘duty of care plan’ that includes ‘the reasonable vigilance measures to allow for risk identification and for the prevention of severe violations of human rights and fundamental freedoms’.

Legislating human rights due diligence: opportunities and potential pitfalls to the French duty of vigilance law DOWNLOAD















Modern Slavery Report 2017-18

The Modern Slavery Report highlights Crown Prosecution Service (CPS)'s efforts during 2017-18 to disrupt, prosecute and improve their response to offending. Findings show a 27 per cent rise in the number of suspects charged with modern slavery and hu...Read More

TAGS: Europe
Counter-Trafficking Directory for Embassies and Consulates Staff

The CT directory gathers key facts and figures about human trafficking in more than 50 countries. It also contains useful contacts to refer the victim or potential victim according to his/her profile: s/he can be in need of immediate protection, nee...Read More

TAGS: Global
Decision No. 8/07 Combating Trafficking in Human Beings for Labour Exploitation

The decision calls on OSCE participating States to: • Consider ensuring that contractors who knowingly use subcontractors involved in traf- ficking for labour exploitation can be held accountable for that crime; • Develop programmes to curb th...Read More

A Typology of Modern Slavery Offences in the UK 2017

Authored by: Christine Cooper, Olivia Hesketh, Nicola Ellis, Adam FairHome Office Analysis and Insight Executive summary This report presents findings from research to create an evidence‐based typology of modern slavery offences in the UK. M...Read More